Having saved their high school from certain doom, the ladies of the first Fairy Tale have gone on to live successful, fun-filled, magical lives. But this is not their tale. Having had a falling out with the girls, Chris, Alina’s younger brother, has turned to a life of womanizing, magical abuse, and supernatural investigation. Through a vision, he finds an expanding girl in trouble, a rogue genie, and a possibly dangerous link to his past. Yearning for adventure, Chris rashly throws himself headfirst– at the time literally– into this new tale.